A Microsoft 365 business should start with the Copilot Chat it already has, pay for Microsoft Copilot where people live in Outlook, Teams and Word, add Claude Team where the work is long documents and careful drafting, and treat Gemini mainly as a choice for firms on Google Workspace.
Most Irish businesses we talk to run on Microsoft 365. Their staff have also tried Claude, ChatGPT or Gemini at home, and someone in the firm has asked which one the business should pay for.
There is no single winner. The right answer depends on what the work is, what you already pay Microsoft for, and how much setting up you are willing to do. This post works through the choice in that order. If you only want the two-way comparison, our Claude vs Copilot guide covers it in more depth.
Start with what Microsoft already gives you
Before you buy anything, check what your existing licences include.
Microsoft Copilot Chat is available at no extra cost to users with an eligible Microsoft 365 business subscription. Microsoft recently renamed its products: Microsoft 365 Copilot is now Microsoft Copilot, and Microsoft 365 Copilot Chat is now Microsoft Copilot Chat. You will see both names for a while.
What Copilot Chat gives you, according to Microsoft's documentation:
- Enterprise data protection. Prompts and responses sit within the Microsoft 365 service boundary, are covered by Microsoft's Data Protection Addendum and are not used to train the underlying models.
- Web grounding. It answers from the web by default, not from your organisation's files.
- Your own content when you add it. People can paste text, upload a file or pick one they have access to. Copilot Chat in Outlook can also reach a person's email, calendar, meetings and a limited set of files.
- EU handling. For EU users, Copilot Chat traffic stays within Microsoft's EU Data Boundary, though web search queries sent to Bing are outside it.
The paid Microsoft Copilot licence adds the part people usually mean by "Copilot": grounding across a person's full work data, including SharePoint, Teams and email, through Microsoft's semantic index. Microsoft notes that what Copilot can do inside Word, Excel and PowerPoint also varies by licence, so check the current feature list for your plan.
For a lot of staff, Copilot Chat is enough for everyday questions and short drafting. Get people using it well before you pay for more.
Where the paid Copilot licence earns its cost
Microsoft Copilot is at its best where the work already happens inside Microsoft's apps:
- catching up on a long Teams meeting or a busy channel
- finding the email or file someone half-remembers
- drafting inside Word or Outlook with the context already there
- people who spend most of the day in meetings and the inbox
If that describes most of your senior staff, Copilot is the obvious place to spend. Our Copilot ROI guide helps work out whether it pays back for a given group.
Where Claude adds value
Claude tends to win on the work that is long, careful and written:
- reviewing and comparing long documents, such as contracts, reports and tenders
- drafting that needs a consistent tone and structure over many pages
- analysis where you want to see the reasoning and check it
- shared projects, where a team keeps instructions and reference documents for a recurring task in one place
Claude Team runs from 2 to 150 seats. Anthropic lists single sign-on, admin controls for connectors and no model training on your content by default. Claude also has a Microsoft 365 connector that can search Outlook, SharePoint, OneDrive and Teams, acting as each signed-in person with only their access. A Global Administrator has to consent once in your tenant. Our Claude pricing guide sets out the current seat prices.
One point to weigh: Anthropic says data for its own Claude service is stored in the US, with transfers covered by Standard Contractual Clauses in its Data Processing Addendum. If your firm has a strict EU-only rule, raise that before you buy.
Claude inside Copilot
There is now a middle route. Microsoft offers Claude models from Anthropic inside some Copilot experiences, including Researcher, Copilot Studio and Copilot in the Microsoft 365 apps, with Anthropic acting as a Microsoft subprocessor.
For Irish businesses the detail matters. Microsoft's documentation says Claude models are switched off by default for tenants in the EU, EFTA and UK, and that they are currently excluded from the EU Data Boundary. An administrator can opt in from the Microsoft 365 admin center and limit access to named users or groups.
This gives Copilot users some of Claude's strengths without a second subscription. It is not the same as Claude Team: you do not get Claude's own projects, its desktop app or its admin console. For a firm that wants both, it is a useful thing to test before adding seats.
Where Gemini fits
Gemini is Google's assistant, and its natural home is Google Workspace. Google includes Gemini in its Workspace business plans, with Gemini in Gmail on every business tier and in Docs, Sheets, Meet and the other apps from Business Standard up. Google says Workspace customer content is not used to train its models outside your domain without permission.
For a Microsoft 365 business, Workspace Gemini mostly means running a second productivity suite. Google's separate Gemini Enterprise product does have generally available connectors for SharePoint, OneDrive, Outlook and Teams, but that is a larger project with its own setup and licensing.
In practice, Gemini makes sense for a Microsoft shop when:
- a team already works in Google Workspace for a client or a project
- you are weighing a wider move to Google anyway
- a specific Google feature solves a problem the others do not
Otherwise, it is usually a third tool that people will not use often enough to justify.
What a Microsoft 365 business should do
- Turn on and train Copilot Chat for everyone. It is already paid for and carries Microsoft's data protection.
- Pick the groups whose work is meetings, email and Office documents and pilot the paid Copilot licence with them.
- Pick the groups whose work is long documents and careful drafting and pilot Claude Team with them, with the Microsoft 365 connector approved and limited to the pilot.
- Decide on Claude models inside Copilot as an admin decision, with the EU Data Boundary point recorded.
- Leave Gemini aside unless a team already works in Google Workspace.
- Review after six to eight weeks on what people actually used, not on what they said they would.
Many firms end up with both Copilot and Claude for different groups. That is a sensible result when the split follows the work. Our AI governance advice covers writing one policy that spans both.
If you would like an independent view on the split for your firm, with training for each group on their own work, tell us about your team.